Sunday, September 7, 2008

Gridlock Economy

Economists love nothing more than being contrarian, and the concepts of the 'tragedy of the commons' and the love of private property are fairly well entrenched among the Economist-reading crowd.   So naturally someone is going to attack this consensus in a popular book with a catchy name.  

The basic idea--that often property rights can prevent anything from getting done--is true enough as far as it goes but doesn't seem like much more than an emphasis on transaction costs.  It does, however, seem like a good way to think about land acquisition for Indian industry.

Though India was the world's top textiles maker at one point, services have recently been the bigger growth story.  It's true that productivity is higher in this sector, owning a great deal to bad government regulations and low investments in human capital and infrastructure by nominally leftist governments.  Plenty of people believe the overall mix should weight more to manufacturing, because it's what all sorts of countries do and it feels better to make real things.  But manufacturing today is increasingly automated, and continues to be highly environmentally destructive.  Regardless, there's certainly room for a larger Indian industrial sector--and the biggest hurdle is acquiring the land for it.

A number of land acquisition targets have been plagued with violence, while others are stalled.  Tata Motors' pullout from a factory designed to build the new Nano car is the latest incident.  It seems obvious that land ought to go to the most productive investment, which is rarely agriculture, and well-capitalized industries are in a good position to offer ample compensation to farmers.  But somehow, land acquisition is rarely easy, owning to several gridlock economy concerns: Uncertain and ill-defined property rights, highly fragmented land ownings, and veto rights exercised by any holdout property owner.  Add to that political concerns in a democratic polity which prioritize the rights of farmers and fail to entirely marginalize the dispossessed.  The new SEZ policy, intended to ease the process through expanding eminent domain rights in certain areas, has sometimes worsened conditions and prompted violence.

I've always been puzzled, though, about regional variations in the success of land acquisitions.  Though Gujarat has by far the greatest number of planned SEZs, it's had few problems.  By contrast, the eastern states of West Bengal and Orissa seem to fail at most things they attempt.  I chalk this up to good governance (barring the occasional religious cleansing) by a politically dominant party in Gujarat, and fragmented, Communist governance in other states.  I recently came accross this argument, that big differences lie in the process.  Instead of simply seizing the land, offering people a stake in the future project and ample compensation seem to be far more effective.  Imagine that.  

Saturday, September 6, 2008

Breaking News

The Fresh Prince episode, She Ain't Heavy, featuring Will and his heaveyset date, also contains an uncredited appearance by John Krasinski--the actor playing Jim Halpert on The Office.  However, the IMDB page doesn't document this.  What else have they been lying to me about!

Really Big Oil

The Financial Times had a good story a while back on how the role of Western oil majors has been replaced by state-owned firms.  With reserves in places such as the North Sea in rapid decline, the new seven sisters, such as Gazprom, Petrobras, or PetroChina, are holding the largest viable reserves of oil and gas.  The failure of some of these firms to ramp up production due to political pressures has sparked a Political Peak Oil that's probably more responsible than Peak Oil for higher energy prices.  

Buffett's purchase of PetroChina was an early recognition of the these firms' investment potential.  Since then, Buffett has exited his position; but a fall in energy prices and political risk has given these companies an attractive valuation.  PetroChina's extensive refinery operations, along with state-set pricing, has lowered their margins, but the Russian companies are doing better business than ever.  Gazprom and Lukoil are trading at about a third off recent highs.

Of course, there are a few concerns.   First, commodity prices are lower.  But these firms are a bargain even with lower oil and natural gas prices.  Second, there is political risk in investing in Russia.  Though this risk is considerable for a company such as Mechel (full disclosure: I am long MTL), it's hard to imagine companies as well connected as Gazprom or Lukoil taking another hit.  The war with Georgia, to the extent it matters at all, increases Russian energy grip over Europe.  Last, state-owned firms may be unlikely to invest in new production.  But current valuations compensates for low growth, and the Russians seem to know what they're doing.  

Friday, September 5, 2008

No Seriously, Don't Drop the Soap

I was looking through the achievements of the 108th Congress, which was Republican dominated in the Bush years, to see if divided governments actually produce better legislation.  Between mandating that Syria not be evil and creating the do not call list, turns out they found time to eliminate prison rape.  

The Wikipedia page links to a prison-themed board game called, I am not making this up, Don't Drop the Soap.  Including such tasteful tokens as "a bag of coke" and a "gat", the goal of the game is to reach parole without, well, dropping the soap and returning to the starting point.  Best of all, the game was designed by the son of Katherine Sibelius--Kansas governor and former Democrat VP hopeful--and sold out of the governor's mansion.  When contacted about the issue, a spokesperson responsed that the parents "are very proud of their son John's creativity and talent."  Elsewhere on the site you can find a picture of the world with lots of dots photoshopped on (presumably supposed to represent store locations, though I don't know why they're retailing in Darfur and have a giant hub in Mato Grosso), discarded thrift store shirts with paint thrown on them retailing for $95, a logo telling me that "it's OK to like cool things," and this loser, hung over at his mom's pool.   

John's company has worked with Uncle Bo's Blues Bar, Homer Hounds, and the Democratic Governors Association.  Nice.

The RNC

One of Andrew Sullivan's many poor calls is that a McCain-Obama fight would let us emerge from the petty cultural wars of Presidents past.  Instead, as usual, we've seen coalitional gridlock along partisan lines.  It's almost as if people are joining teams and rationalizing their actions as they go along  (Why is fantasy politics not around yet?  That would actually give me a reason to pay attention to downstream races).  

Offshore drilling is one of the few new issues to come up, and it brings along really poorly thought out rationalizing on both sides.  The Democrats would have you believe it's not a "real solution" that will not "bring relief at the pump" for "decades to come."  As if every energy proposal must meet some threshold of effectiveness, must lower prices by a certain amount, and impact soon enough or else it is not a genuine Plan of the sort that "gets things done."  I wish the Manhattan Project failed and people never landed on the moon, so people (well, mostly just Thomas Friedman) could stop conceiving of problems as things which are only solved through Plans.  By their criterion, no alternative energy or biofuel program is worthwhile. 

Behind Republican rationalizations is this bizzare longing for energy autarky.  Somehow the rest of the world buys Middle Eastern oil too and they're fine with that.  There's a bad HBO drama out there waiting to be written on the oil trade, in which Schwarzenegger plays President, and the characters wistfully imagine a world in which oil could be traded without violence as any other commodity instead of it being a game.  Buying Russian oil/gas is probably a bad idea though, and Europe really needs to stop doing that.   

Actually, offshore drilling is probably a good idea, because oil is expensive, so drilling oil makes a lot of money, and money is good.  The lack of influence of drilling on oil prices is a good thing, limiting distorting incentives on generating carbon emisssions.  You'll notice no one else complains when they find billions of dollars lying around.   

I would say more about the Republicans had they said things themselves.  But that's not such a horrible thing.  A McCain Presidency would probably be much like Nixon's: Focus on foreign policy, because that's awesome, and let the Democrats pass more or less whatever bill they please.  Bipartisanship is like refusing bribes; both are considered good, but only seriously considered when the other party controls Congress and you want to stay in power.  And maybe not even then.  

Nice Guys Finish First Sometimes

From The Horse, the Wheel, and Language: 

The female bloodline of modern domesticated horses shows extreme diversity... at least seventy-seven ancestral mares are required to account for the genetic variety in modern population.  Meanwhile, the male aspect of modern horse DNA shows remarkable homogeneity.  It is possible that just a single wild stallion was domesticated.

One male horse.  Many female horses.  Think about it.

Stallions are headstrong and violent... A relatively docile and controllable mare could be found at the bottom of the pecking order in many wild horse bands, but a relatively docile and controllable stallion was an unusual individual--and one that had little hope of reproducing in the wild... From the horse's perspective, humans were the only way he could get a girl.

Thursday, September 4, 2008

Re-Elect This Man President

This is pretty awesome.  For more on Putin, see here and here.  For the logic behind the invasion of Georgia, see here.  The argument is that Russia is staving off demographic decline through promoting friendly minority groups in neighboring countries and re-Russifying them.  Rumor has it that one of the reasons that the Yukos chairman was sent to prison is that he wore a polo-neck sweater to the Kremlin instead of a coat and tie.  

The Apple Killer?

There's been a lot of buzz over Google's new browser, which marks Google's most recent step to directly piss off Microsoft.  Like Google's earlier attacks--Google Docs/Spreadsheets, aimed at Microsoft Office, a partnership with Yahoo!--this one aims directly at a core Microsoft monopoly with the goal of radically changing how people do things with computers.  We will now all live and work on a virtualized internet Cloud, right next to Google's plan for actually making money from any of this.  

Seriously though; this looks to more like an attack against Apple than Microsoft.  The more Google succeeds in getting people to embrace internet-based apps, and blurring the link between their work and their hardware, doesn't that make people more likely to view their entire hardware/software system as a commodity, much the way Microsoft succeeded in delinking hardware and software in the 80s?  And the result of that move was to turn hardware into a commodity, which people purchase on the basis of price and performance.  Apple nearly died from that change, and is now sustained by price-insensitive hipsters and the iPod.  

So in a world in which you do everything online, and Macs and PCs are completely compatible, why would you ever use a Mac?  They're more "reliable," sure.  Maybe more user-friendly.  But you're paying more and more for that ever diminishing difference, as PC makers get better and you do more things online.  If you end up doing the same thing on a Mac as a PC, with the same probability of crashing, there's no reason to pay more for the Mac.  


Just a Thought

Suppose McCain wins.  Probably unlikely, but possible.  Then, presumably, Palin is in good shape to run again.  After 12 or 16 years of Republican rule, it's probably unlikely that another Republican would win.  But it's possible, and Palin would certainly top the list of Republican presumptive nominees.  No other Republican who ran this year will have another shot (Definitely not you).  

If McCain wins, Obama loses.  You don't get to miss an opportunity like this and live to try again, so Obama is out for the next one too.  The Democrat next in line will naturally fall to Clinton, as the primary runner-up and scion of the Clinton family.  With her and her husband's speech last week, they plausibly claim they made the effort and wash their hands of the electoral loss, and can instead argue that blame lies with Obama's failure to use Mark Penn-style hardball tactics against the Republican smear-mobile.     

Judging a contest between Palin and Clinton four to eight years from now is a stretch, but I'm going to call it for Clinton anyway.  Republican fatigue and lingering Democrat anger should help her (though demographic reshaping after the 2010 census may help Republicans).  Again, when have there ever been three consecutive elected heads of state from a single party serving full terms?

So by voting for McCain now, you help move Bill Clinton into the White House again.  Something to keep in mind this November.  

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Experience

It's sad what counts as experience these days.  

Ask George H.W. Bush.  By 1991, he was a: war hero, successful businessman, congressman, UN Ambassador, Envoy to China, Director of the C.I.A., professor, Vice President of the most popular administration in recent memory, president for three years, and commander-in-chief during the most popular war ever.  I think that's pretty good qualification to... keep his old job.

And he still lost the presidential election, to a man from Hope.  Sixteen years later, that guy's wife tries, and fails, to run on a platform of experience, losing to a guy mongering hope.  The hope-monger selects as his running mate another man who had earlier critized him for lacking experience.  The two battle against another war hero, who had earlier lost to the son of the most experienced person ever.  This white-haired dude says the hope-monger lacks experience.  So he picks an attractive moose-hunter as running mate.  

Now we're all wondering whether community organizing, or shooting wolves from a plane, or losing track of your houses, or whatever it is that Joe Biden does counts as experience.  Lost in this mess is the governor from New Mexico, who is rumored to have done quite a few things at some point.  

Everybody needs to stop talking about experience, because no one has any, and even if they did, saying that you have it doesn't help you win.

What Will the Next Bubble Be?

Bloomberg has a brief piece on the modern-day prevalence of bubbles.  With low interest rates and rich people being rich people, there's always an irrational investment opportunity in demand.  But now that commodities and energy have finally collapsed, virtually every asset class, from financials, retail, emerging markets, to transportation are down.  So where's the next boom coming from?

The article suggest old Europe and cars.  My personal pick is global infrastructure.  Morgan Stanley raised a big fund to do just this.  Ageing roads and bridges in the U.S. (Minneapolis bridge for one, which my parents drove across every day once.  I'm surprised it's not getting more play at the RNC.), huge demand in the BRICs, and the Middle East is up there as well.  You can make up really big numbers if you want.  Add also all of that "green" and "sustainable" nonsense.  

Why There's A Financial Crisis

Here's a good place to start. First, begin with, as Bernanke says, a global savings glut. Where's all of this money coming from? Middle Eastern and Russian investors sitting on appreciating energy reserves. Asian countries with large and positive trade balances against the U.S. Consumers and businesses in Asia and Europe that save a lot.

Why such high savings? Consumers in Japan and Europe are facing a poor economic outlook and clamp down on spending (Americans will feel this way soon enough). Consumers in Asia are increasingly losing old safety nets (many children), while not gaining modern-day safety nets (pensions); so they save a lot. High-risk countries in Africa and Eastern Europe see large flows of money outside to "safe" environments. Companies in Asia--State Owned Enterprises in China, private firms in India--invest overseas because, frankly, they don't see high returns at home. Despite (or because of) high growth, these countries have not spent political capital on next generation reforms, so domestic investment is dicey. All this money sloshes over to the US, looking for safety.

Here, this money intersects with other bad trends. Consumers increasingly rely on houses as savings, over a stagnant stock market (aided by tax breaks). The Fed is keeping rates low, because hey, growth is anemic and inflation is low as well. Mortage originators have no problem finding investors, and steadily lower lending criteria. Investment Banks don't bear responsibility (in large part) for bad loans, which they package and dispense of as soon as possible. The whole system is propped up by low interest rates and rising house prices, and rationalized by models predicting low delinquency/foreclosure rates.

When housing prices fall, people find themselves in homes worth less than their loan, so they walk out. Low "Teaser" rates reset to higher current rates, and people walk out. Delinquencies and foreclosures spiral, make entire asset classes worthless, and destroy financial sector trust.

This is not exclusively a "subprime" problem. Prime borrowing showed many of the same problems, and "Option ARMs" are going to be a giant issue in the coming years.

The DNC, Part II

Here's another phrase we've been hearing for a while:

Unlike John McCain, I will stop giving tax breaks to corporations that ship jobs overseas, and I will start giving them to companies that create good jobs right here in America.

Pray tell, what exactly are these "tax breaks to send jobs overseas," and how can I apply for one? Turns out they don't really exist, unless you consider the entire international corporate tax system a loophole. This is much like those horrible tax credits for oil companies, which apparently consist of credits for those "alternative fuels" I keep hearing so much about.

Strange that Obama should bring up McCain into this, since this point is actually one of more sensible parts of McCain's platform (the other is offshore drilling). Corporate taxes make little sense--they don't hit any particular person, but rather manifest in the form of higher prices, lower investment, lower wages, and lower capital returns. Even if you're a liberal, these are not good things. It's fine if you want higher taxes for the rich; just tax the money as much as you want once it reaches an actual person.

Naturally, since this tax makes little sense, the US has one of the highest rates in the world. McCain would lower that rate. Now if only somebody would do something about my ~15.3% payroll tax and 10% sales tax. And I'm in the lowest tax bracket!

The DNC, Part I

Watching the Democrats speak last week was an annoying experience. I know, there's no reason to expect much from any politician, and it's not like the Republicans are any better. But still, it's irrational exuberance over something which is just not that good. It's like watching The Wire all over again.

Here's Obama:

We measure progress in the 23 million new jobs that were created when Bill Clinton was president--when the average American family saw its income go up $7,500 instead of down $2,000 like it has under George Bush.

This reflects the larger trend to equate big-picture economic performance with presidential skill. An economic advisor to Obama was on the Colbert Report last night selling this vision, referrencing Larry Bartels work, which shows that growth is higher under Democrats.

Krugman, of all people, is skeptical Baretels, pointing out that it's difficult to point at any specific policy that's responsible. He figures that partisan-specific monetary policy and different voter behavior in booms and busts are responsible for most of the difference.

But you hear quite a bit about how median incomes are stangant and how we're right to whine. Robert Samuelson is good enough to show how these numbers fail to account for spiraling health costs and immigration. I would add that technology and trade have improved quality of life for a given income level.

But even ignoring all of that, it's hard to link Bush's policies--bad though they may be--to household incomes. Loose monetary policy kept interest rates low, tax cuts and rebates brought money to all income groups, added to which we saw surging domestic discretionary spending. Sure, there's plenty to fault here, and there could have been more redistribution downward. But from the standpoint of raising median household income, it's difficult to think of what Bush should have done. Look at Obama McCain's policies and you see... More of the Same! More tax cuts, more spending.

Whatever. There will be a boom by the time the next president is in office, and in all likelihood we're going to hear that "Democrats are better with the economy." Then there will be some foreign crisis and we'll also hear "But Republicans are better on Foreign Policy."