Showing posts with label malaise. Show all posts
Showing posts with label malaise. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

Buffettwatch

Here's Felix Salmon:

“Do you even know who we are?” Talia asked. She thrust her hand into her purse. Out came a grip of shareholder credentials.

“I don’t care,” said the manager. “You’re getting out of this restaurant. Now.”

The women strutted out to a black Mercedes-Benz. As Talia drove, she enumerated a few of her present frustrations. She hated the tacky nowhereness of Omaha. She hated the gawking shareholders who think they own it for a weekend. Most of all, she hated Gorat’s for unjustly ejecting her from the premises. “They thought I was a whore because I’m good-looking and rich!” she exclaimed. “What can I do?”

“They never see the likes of us around Omaha,” replied Tanya.

“We have more shares than all those fuckers,” Talia said…

“Where were you at the cocktail events?” Talia asked me. “We were there with all the ballers. The real deal. You didn’t go to Borsheim’s, did you? That’s where all the suckers go, with one baby B share. The big parties are up at the houses.”

He comments:

This is what happens to the millions of dollars that Buffett earns for his earliest and most loyal investors: they end up fueling the very snobbery and condescension that Buffett himself could never abide.

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

US China Relations

Earlier I was very downcast about the potential for China-American cooperation. James Fallows, among others, hit back against this train of thought by arguing that this sort of diplomatic engagement takes time, and more progress would surely follow.

Now Fallows links to an account of Copenhagen, supposedly by someone "in the room" so to speak during the US-China negotiations. The claim is that China deliberately scuttled the talks to maximize blame on the West generally, and America in particular.

Obviously, I can't vouch for the validity of the claim. But the fact of its plausibility highlights that the climate change talks are prominent not because they represent the pathway to progress, but because they're perpetually deadlocked. The China-US G2 relationship receives so much press coverage not because it is the fundamental driver of global governance, as the Europeans seem to fear, but because that relationship is so badly dysfunctional. The BRICs have the political power of major powers yet behave like the poor countries they really are.

Thursday, October 15, 2009

Some Optimism

orgtheory brings up what I'll dub the cassandra litany: America doesn't manufacture things anymore because all the jobs are going to China, while the US keeps declining in relative influence. Life will be horrible for the next generation.

You hear these things often enough that it's worth pointing out that these claims are misleading at best.

Start with manufacturing. America produces more manufacturing goods than ever before. Even the share of manufacturing goods, as a percent of GDP, has remained roughly constant over time at about ten percent. The recession obviously has hit manufacturing, as have every previous recession, and particular states--Michigan--may have lost some manufacturing plants for good. But other, Southern, states will likely pick up the slack in the coming years, as they have in the past.

It's true--manufacturing jobs are disappearing, even as manufacturing remains strong. But this is a worldwide phenomenon happening not due to trade, but because technology allows for capital to replace people in factories. China is losing millions of manufacturing jobs. So are Japan, Brazil, and many other countries. Don't take my word for it--ask that incorrigible conservative Robert Reich.

Ultimately, this is why things like tire tariffs and industrial policy are wrongheaded. Not because they're bad ways to keep manufacturing jobs in America--though that's true, too. But because in the long run, factory jobs are going the way of farm jobs. Sometime in the next few decades, we'll need about five percent of the population to produce all our food and goods. Everyone else will need to become a service worker, in one way or another, no matter what we do now.

Nor is the US doomed to obsolescence. America has declined in global economic importance, but the big hit was after WWII. At the end of that conflict, America controlled something like half of the world economy. That went down to about a fifth of world output until after Japan and Western Europe recovered. But the US share of output has held up remarkably well since then.

The real story, as the Economist helpfully shows, is that the economic rise of Asia has been parallel by a corresponding fall in Europe's relative position.

If you're a Republican, you say that Regan's tax cuts and deregulation kept America going while Europe started to lag. High immigration and high fertility (the result of big homes, an easier work-life balance for working mothers, and a more abundant economy) have also given America a demographic boost enjoyed by only a few European countries. In fact, most European countries, were they were American states, would rank among the bottom in living standards.

This is likely to remain so for the future. As long as America hosts the world's best Universities, attracts the world's best talent, remains innovative and so on--it will likely not only keep growing, but keep up with the world in relative terms as well. We don't need Summers and his technocrat buddies to figure out where new jobs--green or otherwise--are going to come from. Despite all their progress, India and China would love to have America's problems rather than the ones they currently have. The news tends to focus on growth rates, so it's easy to forget that America's per capita GDP is sixteen times higher than China's, with a similar level of income inequality.

People still focus on the stagnating middle class, two Americas, etc. Leaving aside the issue of whether that's an accurate description, there's a real issue here. Class mobility is low, and the collapse of manufacturing has left fewer good jobs for unskilled workers. But CEO pay and income tax cuts for the rich are minor points in this story. To the extent that policy can fix any of these issues, education reform and encouraging family stability have to top the list.

But we'll make more progress on the tough stuff by doing less China India hysteria, less angst about trade, less nostalgia about manufacturing, and less doomsday talk about what is, after all, the world's best system for wealth creation.

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Dream of Californication

California has long led the country. Now, it's totally dysfunctional.

The reasons for California's problems are well-known. Democrats won't cut spending; Republicans won't cut taxes. Legislative lockjam prevents action even in the best of times, and in the worst results in governance catastrophe the like of which are almost impossible to imagine in a modern country.

Is the rest of the country so far off?

Consider: the government has barely raised taxes in decades. Bush I's decision to raise them, and go back on a pledge, is widely thought to have cost him a re-election. Clinton raised some, but Bush reversed those and extended them further. Better to raise the deficit. Obama's campaign took as a central plank that taxes would not rise for the middle class. Relative to the status-quo at the end of the Clinton years, this was actually a tax decrease for the vast majority of Americans. It is becoming virtual political suicide to raise taxes on anyone except the rich--and even they complain bitterly.

Meanwhile, spending is growing out of control. Huge outlays are certain to happen on healthcare, education, and energy. Health care reform promises to curb costs, but the missing step--the one between mandating coverage for all and lowering health care bills--is totally absent. No doubt the White House's technocrats have ideas, but Congress shows no signs of letting them pass. Even the Republicans are raising all hell about 'rationing' health care--even for government funded care, which makes no sense. Iraq is more peaceful, so the Defense budget is down a bit, but Afghanistan is still going. It's soon going to be time for America's decennial war--my bet's on an irregular war within Pakistan.

Obama's term so far highlights the crisis that the legislative branch has fallen into. One might reasonably think that after winning a decisive mandate, the Democrats would find it easy to pass their favored bills. One would be mistaken. Excepting Regan's first few years, no President in recent memory has managed to pass his favored bills. Clinton's major legislative achievements are all things Republicans would love--NAFTA and welfare reform. Bush could not privatize Social Security or pass health care reform even with his majority. And now Obama can barely get Congress to cut the number of GM dealers. The one agency that acquitted itself well during the financial crisis has been the Fed, a fact largely arising from the fact that it is not accountable to Congress. The more democratic our institutions, the worse they perform.

Congress can do two things well: spend and bail out. From Wall Street to Detroit, federal funds sustain corporate America, and corporate America in turn finances Congress. In other countries, we call this crony capitalism. The deficit is huge this year--which isn't a horrible thing--but projections in the future show trillion dollar yearly deficits trailing off into the future.

True, it's hard to predict the future. But suppose the economy fails to get better as scheduled. Say we've all been living beyond our means for the past years, and need to readjust to a more sustainable level of living. Unemployment will lag growth, and the rich will not contribute to the federal pot. Then we'll face poor government revenue, spending that can't decrease, and taxes that can't go up. The legislature can't do anything productive. We'll face government debts that will get harder to pay.

In other words: California. Of course, if America starts to look like California, where will California be?

Friday, June 19, 2009

Live from New York, it's...

I really hate those blogs/articles/reports from some heavily populated part of the world. After all, millions of people seem to live there just fine, so what exactly is newsworthy about that? Not to mention the Survivor phenomenon, where people trek to obscure places--where people have been living just fine for tens of thousands of years--and pat themselves on the back for surviving. Even the drama, I'm sure, is more intense at the village ten miles over.

None of this will stop me from blogging about New York, or from repeating the cliches about it.

This place really is Trantor writ small. The insane density means that you get everything at your doorstep. The total cosmopolitanism provides insane levels of variety and diversion. While, somehow, every square block of the city maintains its own micro-local character. A random hundred yard stretch will yield more hustle, bustle, culture, and interest than a whole neighborhood in Chicago (or, at least, some other city).

And then there's the pizza. Chicago-style pizza is fine, but in Chicago fashion, you have to hit those traditional places which sell it at a price. New York has democratized the pizza, throwing stands and tiny shops city-wide. They've done it with street food too--this place has the food quality of somewhere far poorer (go immigrants go).

It also, apparently, has a transportation system likewise. I'm mildly amused by the prevalence of rickshaws. Why are hipsters biking tourists around, rain or shine, as if they were in Calcutta-while the guy who is actually from Calcutta is driving a cab? Our generation, bereft of challenges, has apparently decided to pretend like hundreds of years of economic development never happened. This absolves them of the perennial guilt they hold--the original sin of the left-liberal--while giving them something to occupy themselves with. I hope climate change washes every last green fanatic into the sea. I laugh inside every time they complain it's too cold.

Fortunately, as far as I can tell, the hipster rebellion here is just one of a million mutinies, rather than being a social experiment gone horribly, horribly wrong and dominant. Maybe I should check out Brooklyn though. [ed-or else stop being cranky]

Fun fact: the guy who came in to fix my door assured me that New York's decline in the 70s and 60s dated back to its failure to attract container shipping, which went (along with ancillary industries) to Jersey. Sounds plausible, and would also explains why Newark crapped out a bit after New York. But then they (again, a bit later) got a mayor with national aspirations! All you budding politicians out there--find some manufacture heavy part of the country about to decline, then offer to run and fix it. The people will love you forever, or at least until you fail the Florida primary (really, what was that strategy? Step 1: Get New York expats in the South to vote for you. Step 2: ??? Step 3: Win! Send that strategist back to powerpoint school).

I guess the people are supposed to be really rude, but the first time I was walking down the street, someone said hi. Go figure.

Even the cabs are more advanced. They have these nice LCD screens in the back showing the local news, from which I confirmed that local news is consistently horrible around the country. Difference, though is that the pseudo-sexual banter between the hosts here is just about subway etiquette.

Bottom Line: Hyde Park needs to die. Seriously, I don't care what the density is, throw down some retail and food, and a hotel too. And stay up past ten. If bumfuck, IA has fast food options at three in the morning, so should a (nominal) College town. While you're at it, connect to public transport like a reasonable part of the city.

Saturday, October 18, 2008

Malaise Theory

I've talked about this a lot but never really coherently.

The idea is that many times in history, you have a problem where a belief system becomes the established tradition but proves untenable given social changes.  Then you have a generation which only conceives of things in certain ways, while realizing that the foundations of their thought lack solid roots.

Pankaj Mishra offers a good overview of how this works in the context of Buddhism.  The Buddha was historically contingent, in that he needed to arise in some sort of rapidly changing cultural world.  The actual environment in India was one in which urban republics rose in power and the Brahminical elite was rapidly dispossessed in favor of roving bands of ascetic and a new merchant elite.  Lack of faith in the old morality, rising individualism and wealth, and social disconnect led to a growing intellectual dissatisfaction.  Buddhism's adoption of "dukkha" or the unsatisfactoriness of life as a key part of the doctrine was a natural choice given the social reality.  
Nietzche gets at a very similar phenomenon with the whole "God is dead" line.  The point being that the Christian myth--that life ought to be lived in accordance with an a system of absolute morals, while passions are denigrated and reason elevated--was increasingly at odds with the rise of science and secular culture.  I guess you could call this 'nihlism' broadly but it seems to me a more specific historical trend.

There are various possible responses.  Nietzche called attention to new "secular gods" and these really did become very popular.  Or you could just do drugs.  Being some sort of superman was Nietzche's suggested response, but it doesn't seem particularly feasible.  Generally, people seek validation in some larger system, and destroying one usually leads to a quick search for another.  The common response seems to be a version of utopianism.  On the left, there is this sense that if previous human arrangements universally result in human suffering, then somehow we can build a better society through the explicit rejection of all received wisdom and the adoption of a permanent revolution.  So you get this studious, affected distaste of just about everything, anger and grievance for the sake of it, combined with a hope in "change;" damn the actual need or path the change will take.

You see a response on the right too, especially among neoconservatives.  This ideology really came from a plea for a more humble and gradual approach for foreign and domestic policy, and was primarily motivated through a disappointment in liberal institutions, but somehow morphed into a paranoid style of politics.  From Cheney to Iraq, you have a well-chronicled story of disgust at liberals combined with relative ignorance and a limitless belief in the transformability of society (Iraqi or American) through partisan means.  Much as it pains me to say, something similar seems to happen with the free-market fundamentalists, especially once they get a bit of power in other countries.  This is not to say I'm a fan of Naomi Klein--you may know what I think of her--and many of the people involved are not conservatives.  

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Cultural and Intellectual Consequences of Financial Collapse

I'm no Naomi Klein, but many crises have been followed by large shifts in opinion. One, I think there will be significant backlash overseas. The European bankers, Chinese state-run investment firms, and Sovereign Wealth Funds all bought worthless US paper all the way down and were rarely transparent about it to their investors. I imagine we'll see angry conspiracy theories thrown out about malevolent American coercion forcing these trades, some of this directed at the funds too. This will curb global capital flows and trust; both foreign money coming in and the willingness of people to accept American money flowing out.

Obviously, the crisis will be blamed on poor "regulation" and free market practices. For why that's not the best way of looking at it, see Cowen. But the outrage against corporate overlords will be strong, and there will be a strong push towards greater federal oversight. My guess is that retroactive analysis will emphasize the powerful and beneficial role of the Federal Reserve and Treasury in stopping the crisis, and people will demand similar action elsewhere. After all, we bailed out Bear Sterns, so why not bail out the little guy as well? It's easy to look at the situation and see failing markets and effective federal regulators.

Government manipulations of the housing market--tax credits for capital gains and mortgage payments--are likely to continue.

So I guess this is just saying that the country will shift left, which is what many people expected anyway. It's not the worst thing in the world. As Lawrence Summers said recently, markets have worked well in delivering people tradable goods and services, while problems lie in the delivery of social services such as healthcare, education, and poverty assistance.

Intellectually I have to imagine that there will be a, well, malaise. It's been close to a decade now of stagnant growth in GDP and equity prices; combine that with a global crisis, a housing collapse, one war that's seen as failed (Iraq) and another that's seen as misguided (terror), higher commodity prices, and failures in leadership from politics and economics. Everyone talks about the iconic status of Jon Stewart in this generation, but maybe we'll see the more disaffected and hopeless side of that. Timewise, I'm thinking late '80s-early '90s, or mid to late '70s as a model. I suspect a new narcotic will become popular. If nothing else, people will start to spend all of their time on the internet. People will associate with others on finer and finer gradiations; trust and community will collapse as xenophobia rises. Materially, it will be the best time ever in human history.

Looking back, this doesn't make a lot of sense, but predicting things is hard.