Saturday, October 17, 2009

Some Pessimism for Optimists

Forecasting is impossible unless you're this guy; everyone else looks at an uncertain world and makes some prediction with error. The optimists think things will get better; the pessimists that it will get worse.

The optimists have been overwhelmingly correct over the past few hundred years. Health, wealth, and freedom have all gone up; poverty, intolerance, and malaria have all gone down.

Yet people keep praising the pessimists. Pessimists are graded on the strength of their best prediction; optimists on their worst.

Compare Fukuyama with Roubini. Fukuyama's prediction--that liberal, free-market democracy would rule the world--was bold if not entirely innovative. But it's held up enormously well. Global conflict is down; freedom and free markets have spread. Yet Fukuyama gets absolutely no respect. People focus on the flaws in his call--there is still some conflict in the world; some countries are still repressive. Successes in optimistic predictions, no matter how large or important, are ignored as representing flukes or are else seen as "unsustainable". More generally, optimists are taken as terminally deluded captives of some authority. They're sellout shrills, and deserve no respect. Serious people are eternally critical.

Then there's Roubini. He's spent the last ten years warning about disasters that have never happened. A dollar crisis, balance of payments crisis, and so forth. Most of those disasters have still not happened. Then he got to doomesdaying on the housing market late. But everyone only remembers this last prediction, and calls him a prophet. He goes around New York with a bevy of hot twenty-somethings; Fukuyama doesn't get the same treatment.

The lesson is clear for future prognosticators. If you say things will get better; you'll be denounced as wrong if it doesn't hold up, and a suck-up even if they do. If you say they'll get worse; just wait until something bad happens and you get hailed for your prescience.

Friday, October 16, 2009

Vietnam Revisionism, Iraq, and Afghanistan

Lexington reminds me to bring up a vastly under-discussed topic: Vietnam Revisionism.

Counterinsurgency broke the news after Petraeus and McChrystal, but it was actually very big in the popular and military imagination during the '60s as well. Mao's success in China sparked a huge discussion of how to conduct and defeat insurgency. For obvious reasons, the Vietnam War continued this trend.

Reading A Better War, a classic revisionist account of Vietnam, is like looking at Iraq all over again. The initial commanders in both wars--Westmoreland in Vietnam, Tommy Franks and others in Iraq--were basically clueless about how to tackle local insurgency. Westmoreland, for instance, focused on body counts and firepower. He threw artillery and air power at guerrillas, and focusing on winning battles. He exuded optimism and threw out made-up statistics during press conferences. As in Iraq, this led nowhere.

Then you had new generals in both wars. In Vietnam, General Abrams came in. He replaced "search-and-destroy" missions with ones focused on "clear-and-hold" to implement a policy of civilian defense. He focused more on training native Vietnamese units. This coincided with Nixon's "surge" strategy of escalating the conflict to leave on better terms. The dramatic change in policy as a result of following counterinsurgency doctrine and the dramatic change in the outcome of the war in America's are not in question. Needless to say, the surge under Petraeus and Odierno, and the shift in American doctrine towards COIN, was a similar story.

The disputed part about Vietnam Revisionism is whether Abrams' efforts were enough to win the war in the long run. North Vietnam enjoyed enormous support from Communist states, while Congress eventually killed all military aid to South Vietnam. In the Revisionist counterfactual, limited military aid would have allowed an insurgency-free South Vietnam to sustain direct attacks from North Vietnam.

I think a fairly convincing argument can be made for that scenario. But in any event; there are better and worse ways of fighting insurgencies, and it takes a while to develop the competency and leadership capable of fighting them.

The success of counterinsurgency in Vietnam and Iraq doesn't imply that it will work in Afghanistan, a very different country. Nor will it tell you if Vietnam, Iraq, or Afghanistan were ultimately worth fighting. Just because a given tactic can win a war doesn't mean the war is worthwhile.

But from the point of view of South Vietnam, at any rate, it probably was. South Vietnam remained mired in poverty for twenty years after its war, while it enjoyed growth under a free market before the war, and would probably have enjoyed even greater success had it won the war--something like a North Korea/South Korea analogue (I might even go so far as to say that if you think the Korean war was worth fighting, than you should have supported South Vietnam in 1975, even if you opposed sending troops in during the 60s).

Thursday, October 15, 2009

Some Optimism

orgtheory brings up what I'll dub the cassandra litany: America doesn't manufacture things anymore because all the jobs are going to China, while the US keeps declining in relative influence. Life will be horrible for the next generation.

You hear these things often enough that it's worth pointing out that these claims are misleading at best.

Start with manufacturing. America produces more manufacturing goods than ever before. Even the share of manufacturing goods, as a percent of GDP, has remained roughly constant over time at about ten percent. The recession obviously has hit manufacturing, as have every previous recession, and particular states--Michigan--may have lost some manufacturing plants for good. But other, Southern, states will likely pick up the slack in the coming years, as they have in the past.

It's true--manufacturing jobs are disappearing, even as manufacturing remains strong. But this is a worldwide phenomenon happening not due to trade, but because technology allows for capital to replace people in factories. China is losing millions of manufacturing jobs. So are Japan, Brazil, and many other countries. Don't take my word for it--ask that incorrigible conservative Robert Reich.

Ultimately, this is why things like tire tariffs and industrial policy are wrongheaded. Not because they're bad ways to keep manufacturing jobs in America--though that's true, too. But because in the long run, factory jobs are going the way of farm jobs. Sometime in the next few decades, we'll need about five percent of the population to produce all our food and goods. Everyone else will need to become a service worker, in one way or another, no matter what we do now.

Nor is the US doomed to obsolescence. America has declined in global economic importance, but the big hit was after WWII. At the end of that conflict, America controlled something like half of the world economy. That went down to about a fifth of world output until after Japan and Western Europe recovered. But the US share of output has held up remarkably well since then.

The real story, as the Economist helpfully shows, is that the economic rise of Asia has been parallel by a corresponding fall in Europe's relative position.

If you're a Republican, you say that Regan's tax cuts and deregulation kept America going while Europe started to lag. High immigration and high fertility (the result of big homes, an easier work-life balance for working mothers, and a more abundant economy) have also given America a demographic boost enjoyed by only a few European countries. In fact, most European countries, were they were American states, would rank among the bottom in living standards.

This is likely to remain so for the future. As long as America hosts the world's best Universities, attracts the world's best talent, remains innovative and so on--it will likely not only keep growing, but keep up with the world in relative terms as well. We don't need Summers and his technocrat buddies to figure out where new jobs--green or otherwise--are going to come from. Despite all their progress, India and China would love to have America's problems rather than the ones they currently have. The news tends to focus on growth rates, so it's easy to forget that America's per capita GDP is sixteen times higher than China's, with a similar level of income inequality.

People still focus on the stagnating middle class, two Americas, etc. Leaving aside the issue of whether that's an accurate description, there's a real issue here. Class mobility is low, and the collapse of manufacturing has left fewer good jobs for unskilled workers. But CEO pay and income tax cuts for the rich are minor points in this story. To the extent that policy can fix any of these issues, education reform and encouraging family stability have to top the list.

But we'll make more progress on the tough stuff by doing less China India hysteria, less angst about trade, less nostalgia about manufacturing, and less doomsday talk about what is, after all, the world's best system for wealth creation.

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Petraeus, Don't Betray Us

Ever since the last election, I've kept an eye on the 2012 race. Like many people, my attention has been mainly on current and former Republican governors--Mitch Daniels, Pawlenty, Jindal, Huckabee, Romney --who could plausibly run as pragmatic technocrats focusing on fiscal prudence and competence in governance.

Intrade has another possible pick--Petraeus is trading at just under a ten percent chance at the Republican nomination.

This would be pretty interesting. Republicans have a long history of nominating war heroes and generals--basically every nominee from Eisenhower to McCain was a general, war hero, war President, or played a war hero in Hollywood. Bush 2000 and Nixon are a couple of exceptions. The military is one of the most admired institutions, and Petraeus in particular is highly regarded.

Moreover, unlike some past candidates--Colin Powell--Petraeus is fairly political. He's great with the press, worked some serious politics to get to where he is today, and is on the record as expressing interests in the Presidency. Sure, half of Congress probably has Presidential interests depending on the day of the week, but it's a little rarer in the military.

He isn't known for any sentiments on domestic policy, but that's exactly his promise. It means no long record of incriminating or flip-flopping statements, so can enter the campaign with a blank slate. People will project whatever they want onto him, so he can be all things to all people until he gets elected (sounds familiar...). I'm sure he's a smart guy--put him in the room with a few advisors, and he'll learn everything he needs to.

Of course, the nominee, and winner, in 2012 will be determined by future events we can't predict. But it is possible to sketch out the path in which Petraeus would do very well:

The economy keeps getting worse. Debt keeps rising. Obama exits Afghanistan, and things get worse there and in Pakistan. Terrorists strike somewhere. People perceive the government as corrupt and ineffectual; and its stance on national security as weak.

Petraeus steps in as the candidate of authority. His patriotism and competence are beyond question. It really doesn't matter what he says, as long as he comes off as reasonably intelligent and competent. This would be another Obama-like "branded" campaign, in which the overall image and tone of the candidate overshadows everything else. McCain tried to run something like this (Country First), and almost won (and would still have won if not for the post-Lehman collapse. I'm surprised I don't see more conspiracy theories/spite about that.).

Can you imagine trying to run attack ads against a successful war general? Not fun. All of the other potential Republican candidates have pissed off someone else in the camp at some point or another. Petraeus is arguably the only Republican alive who earns the respect, if not the outright adulation, of not only most Republicans, but many others as well.

Of course, if things turn out differently--the economy gets better, the wars end up going well--there will be much less space for a Petraeus candidacy. Either way, civilian-military relations seem be decidedly chillier under Obama, and it'll be interesting to see how this plays out.

Monday, October 12, 2009

Graveyard of Empires

One thing you hear all of the time is that "Afghanistan is the graveyard of empires". It's taken down everyone from Alexander the Great to the British to the Soviets, so America should probably stay away. Or else just go in all the way just to prove how America is so amazing.

Well, check out the history of Afghanistan on Wikipedia. You'll see that Alexander the Great conquered Afghanistan (then Bactria) just fine, and Greeks ran empires in the region for hundreds of years. Other successful conquerors include the Persians, Scythians, Mongols, Arabs, Sikhs... the list really goes on. Historically, Afghanistan has been the stepping-stone of empire rather than its graveyard.

It's true, the British had some setbacks there. But ultimately both the British and Russians had victories in the region.

But none of this answers the question of whether Afghanistan can be "won" today or not. Iraq, for instance, has historically been very easy to conquer; and, yes, any country today with a sizable standing army probably would have found it reasonably easy to both conquer and pacify Iraq. India or China, if either had the logistics capacities and local defense bases, could probably have done a decent job at it. But it proved to be very difficult for America today nonetheless.

The Soviets, for instance, found Afghanistan tough going--even though the Russians enjoyed some success there over a hundred years ago. The past is very poor at predicting the outcome of insurgency today. Not even the Soviet example is a perfect indicator of how things may go in Afghanistan, as things are very different. There are no Stinger missiles or foreign countries supplying insurgents today, for instance.

Rather than misreading inapplicable historical examples, it would be nice if the media offered some more cost-benefit analysis on this sort of foreign adventure. Here, I'm genuinely agnostic: cutting and running would seriously hurt counter-terrorist operations, but even total success is not worth an infinite amount of money and lives. It seems silly to skimp and scrounge for every last penny on a health reform bill, but then say that because this particular war seems good in comparison to a pretty lousy one, it's worth throwing no end to money towards it.

It also seems odd to slam McChrystal for behaving as a neo-MacArthur in demanding more troops for the mission. Isn't that what Shinseki did before the Iraq War, before getting fired and then applauded for his willingness to speak up? It's probably true in both cases that generals shouldn't be the final determinants of troop levels (at least in wars of choice), because they aren't in a position to weigh the benefits of more troops with costs elsewhere. But really that's just a reason to stop engaging in wars of choice, so that these issues will stop rearing up.

The news already does a pretty poor job of covering international news; maybe if they finally do a poor enough job, no one will care, and these sorts of wars will stop happening.

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

The Uncommon App

I'm sorry to revisit an old, and extremely tiresome, debate. If you didn't go to Chicago, feel free to tune out. But this is exactly right:
For the past few years, elite colleges and universities have ... unveiled some very generous “grand prizes” in the form of making college free for low-income students,eliminating loans for others, or capping payments for improperly defined “middle income” individuals. But while this makes for a big payoff, the school doesn’t have to worry too much—they can keep costs down by controlling who they let in and the extent to which they sell these policies to lower-income students.

To an elite institution, these policies are a win-win calculation: good press for seeming generous, but it doesn’t have to worry about going too far in letting in these more expensive low-income students because it doesn’t take a proactive approach to recruiting them and convincing them to apply

if institutions are truly committed to improving their socioeconomic diversity, then they need to do more just announce a new policy with a flashy press release. Instead, admissions officers should do a better job visiting lower-income high schools, forming relationships with guidance counselors where they can, and generally take a more proactive approach to identifying promising lower-income students. Admittedly, this is labor intensive and has some costs, but without a greater commitment, these generous financial aid policies will be little more than a flashy exercise with little risk of significant success.
Many people point out that income mobility is pretty bad right now. The argument, which one gets by innuendo, is that Republicans have raided the economy and are keeping all of the jobs for themselves. There may be some truth to this. But overwhelmingly, the path to a better life is through education; and schools are not following through.

The UofC in particular is pretty damnable. On the plus side, it doesn't really do legacies, and has historically done well by taking in smart kids who are discriminated against elsewhere (Jews in the 50s, Asians today. This analogy actually goes pretty far. Schools started looking at evaluations and so forth because otherwise they would have to admit Jews who scored high on the SATs, and they use essays today in a similar way for Asians.). On the down side, 13% of Chicago students have Pell Grants, a reasonable indicator of low family income. This beats Harvard, but trails a number of other schools--like MIT and Amherst--and falls way behind the California system, which have over the past half century dramatically expanded to offer a great education to many deserving kids.

It's bad enough that elite Universities like Chicago have chosen, instead of opening up like UC Berkeley, to hunker down and amass enormous endowments which they display mostly for prestige (or else blow it all on gyms and fancy science buildings). What's worse is that people complain when someone actually tries to do something about it.

That's what the Uncommon App debate was about. The rich and connected kids already know about Chicago and can get their maids to fill out ten forms duplicating their home address. It's promising low-income students--who are put off enough by the high sticker price--who you get by making it easier to apply. No, putting the application in a slightly less hokey and pretentious package will not destroy the brand.

Ultimately, this is not a big issue, and I'm almost sure I'm the only person still thinking about it. But what's at stake is the character of the school and how accessible you are. One side wants to let in the elect, while keeping out the lazy rif-raf, and then withdrawing behind those walls to rise in oaths of brotherhood to those they kept outside. And I think this about concludes the series of screechy op-eds I never sent in to the Maroon.

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Healthcare Reform

Most of the healthcare reform bills being considered entrench the status quo, which is unsustainable. What would a better plan look like? Here's my cut:

1) Health Savings Accounts
The "use it or lose it" penalty for health savings accounts would no longer apply--put money in, tax free, into a health savings account; and you can use it whenever you want. The money would also be invested and interest accumulates in your account (if you don't like stocks, they can be put in inflation-protected Treasuries). Once you get old, you have the chance to move some of this money into your retirement account.

2) Mandatory Release of Costs for Hospital Procedures
Put them on the internet, nail them to churches, print them on the back of driver licences, burn them into the backs of people's retnas for all I care. It's insane that people will drive for miles to shave off a penny per gallon of gas but don't--and can't--know how much an MRI costs.

3) A Public Plan
The public plan would only offer catastrophic coverage (ie, severe emergency room care only) with high deductibles. Under the government plan, you, by default, put in ten percent of your salary into a Health Savings Account to handle most health spending. Preventative care is covered.

4) Guaranteed issue, community rating, and mandatory coverage
Everyone needs to buy health insurance. You can buy the government plan, or a private one. No insurer can turn down anyone who wants care, and can only charge premiums based on age.

5) Insurance Exchanges
All insurers must provide a "basic" plan that offers similar catastrophic care as the public option, as well as a more traditional package. Benefits are standardized across the two levels to allow easy comparison shopping. These exchanges are set up on a national level. All insurance spending (but not health account savings) is taxed.

That's it. The left should love the plan because it eliminates (or greatly reduces) the uninsured population while allowing people with pre-existing conditions to purchase insurance. The public option keeps insurers "honest." The right should love the plan because it increases competition--instead of insurance companies making their money by refusing care, they now make money by holding costs down. Young people should love it because they can purchase the public option cheaply. And everyone should love the plan because it reduces healthcare costs: the more people are accountable for their own spending, the more costs go down.

In the long-run, Medicare and Medicaid would be obsolete. People will start entering retirement with lots of money to pay for their own care; those (young or old) who can't afford care will be given subsidies to buy their own insurance (paid out of taxing insurance coverage). This will stave off the government's looming fiscal collapse.

Naturally, we're not going to see anything like this plan.

Sunday, September 13, 2009

Obama v. Daniels

While Obama starts a trade war with China, Mitch Daniels successfully leads a trade delegation there.

Just sayin'. Just as Kevin Rudd gained power in Australia partially on the basis of his foreign policy chops, and as it helped Tim Geithner gain the Secretary of Treasury position, it's easy to imagine skill at foreign negotiations become an increasingly important qualification for the Presidency. Obama definitely benefitted from this trend.

Then again, Rudd also arguably benefited from being sighted at a New York strip club, so maybe Australian politics is just out there.

Healthcare and Technocrats

I've been growing increasingly worried as I look deeper into how healthcare technocrats think. Here's a piece from CAP:
When Texas capped non economic medical malpractice damages to $250,000 in 2003, most conservatives argued that the reform would free doctors from having to prescribe unnecessary treatment. It didn’t happen. According to the Dartmouth research on disparities in health care spending, many Texan doctors are still prescribing aggressive treatments that don’t improve outcomes. In fact, as of 2006, Texas was still at the top of the list of high-spending states.
Ignore the bit on malpractice; just look at the bit on Texas as a high-spending state. But high spending in this context really refers to high Medicare spending; and Medicare funds substitute for other health dollars. Overall, it's not clear that Texas is spending "too little" or "too much" on healthcare.

But suppose it, and all other "high spending" areas, were overall high spenders. What would that mean? If you check out the link, you'll see what the Dartmouth people call "high spending" areas. By and large, these are urban areas with lots of poor people, and large huge health needs.

Just consider how silly this exercise would be if we looked at any other profession. What if we found that lawyers cost more in New York than Albany. Does all that extra New York spending reflect "waste" that we can costlessly cut through bureaucrats? Or is it just that the cost of items varies; and that cities in particular have high costs due to high costs of living, etc.?

It's even worse for healthcare because different populations and people will respond differently to medicine. You need to do a far more detailed analysis on the subgroups involved, etc. to get an idea of how medical dollars are being spent. But the Dartmouth group doesn't do this; they're convinced that 30% of healthcare spending is waste, and any difference in costs or outcomes around the country can be attributed to that.

It is probably true that a lot of health spending is wasted or unneccessary, for any number of reasons, some government related. But I doubt these problems can be easily fixed by cutting health spending for poor urban areas. In the past, when Medicare has cut reimbursements, doctors have responded by increasing the number of billed operations, and increasing the total cost. So top-down economizing could even have perverse results.

This is a tough issue, and clearly reform--particularly of Medicare--is necessary. But I have an instinctive fear of overly-ambitious policy wonks and technocrats. We'll see what kind of difference they make to policy.

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Obama's Healthcare Speech

Some thoughts on the speech:

I think it's interesting that two of the proposals that Obama outlined--mandates and taxing employer-provided care--were signature issues on the campaign trail as well. Mandates were one of the few big policy differences between him and Clinton--and he was opposed to them. Then Obama put out many, nasty ads against McCain because he wanted to tax healthcare. It's true, as many people say, that Obama's focus on healthcare was a defining characteristic of his campaign, and attracted many voters. But his actual policy stances have turned a full-180. Bizarrely, no one seems to have noticed, but I suspect that this is one reason why the issue is proving so intractable.

And stop blaming Republicans. Democrats, just a couple of years ago, showed no willingness to go forward with Social Security reform, and that's going to cost all of us who are young hundreds of thousands of dollars. Opposition parties sometimes behave as if they're in opposition, deal. If you have a majority in both Houses, just pass a bill.

I also see that one of the ridiculed conservative ideas on healthcare would be to "turn Medicare into a privatized voucher program." But that would be amazing! That forces people to be more responsible about their spending, while still funding it for people who don't have it. Note that countries with universal private insurance mandates--like Switzerland or the Netherlands--give out exactly these types of subsidies for people who can't afford care.

Obama apparently wants to cut Medicare Advantage. See Marginal Revolution for a run-down of these plans; basically they are plans which allow seniors to purchase additional care. So while people under 65 would be forced to purchase healthcare; people over 65 would be limited in their ability to purchase healthcare.

Also check out this great interview with a hematologist criticizing the "Dartmouth" approach to healthcare, which is convinced that 30% of healthcare costs as the result of waste and fraud, and can be cut through technocratic means. The counterpoint is that areas of high Medicare spending spend a lot for a reason. Atul Gawande singled out McAllen, for instance, as an area of high Medicare spending. But it's also a poor area with many health problems and little private insurance; the system overbills Medicare to sustain itself, but overall it's not a high cost area. Other analysis suggests that higher health spending is, in fact, related to better outcomes.

Monday, September 7, 2009

Legos

Here's the NYT on Lego's rebirth:

But the story of Lego’s renaissance — and its current expansion into new segments like virtual reality and video games — isn’t just a toy story. It’s also a reminder of how even the best brands can lose their luster but bounce back with a change in strategy and occasionally painful adaptation.

Nevertheless, Lego hasn’t entirely shed its Scandinavian sense of social mission when it comes to making toys. It kept quality high and never moved any manufacturing to China, avoiding the lead paint scare and grabbing market share when rivals stumbled amid multiple recalls.

Maybe it was a great strategy for Lego not to outsource manufacturing. Maybe it would even have been a good idea for Denmark to prevent Lego from doing so. But protectionism isn't moral. What's moral, and in line with a social mission, is helping millions of people rise out of absolute deprivation.

At least we're consistent in lauding aid agencies and local manufacturing--both fail to help poor people, and both are socially conscious.

Nussbaum on College

Here's what Martha Nussbaum says about College:
It’s easy to think that college classes are mainly about preparing you for a job. But remember: this may be the one time in your life when you have a chance to think about the whole of your life, not just your job. Courses in the humanities, in particular, often seem impractical, but they are vital, because they stretch your imagination and challenge your mind to become more responsive, more critical, bigger. You need resources to prevent your mind from becoming narrower and more routinized in later life. This is your chance to get them.
This claim is often made, and I would probably agree with it. But I don't think it's too much to ask that the claim be made through slightly less hackneyed language. You would never drop two hundred grand more on a house because a highly interested party said it would "stretch your imagination and challenge your mind to become bigger," so use some of that supposedly non-narrow, non-routinized brainpower to write something better.

Of course, maybe I'm assuming too much about College kids. Maybe they need to major in the Humanities before they can realize how tired and bad some of the arguments are for taking the Humanities.

Sunday, September 6, 2009

How Financial Markets are like Highways

Cheap Talk makes the interesting point that Finance is like driving in highways, but takes a sour view on arbitrage:

The parallels are clear between financial markets and driving in traffic. Arbitrage is the controlling force. For example, on the freeways arbitrage equalizes the traveling time across lanes, the commuters version of the efficient markets hypothesis.

You don’t have to have spent much time on the freeways to understand why arbitrage is not always efficient. An individual driver can get where he is going faster by changing lanes, but since there is a fixed capacity on the road this is always at the expense of somebody else. In equilibrium the total distance traveled by all is the same as if everybody were required to stay in their lanes. The arbitrage turns out to be a pure social loss due to the increased frequency of accidents.

I take a more sympathetic view to arbitrage (cars careening across highways). Here are three theorems in highway-finance:

1) Inefficient Highways Hypothesis: If not all drivers are willing to change lanes, differences in travel times can persist across lanes. The lack of 'leverage' on highways--you only control your own car--sharply limits efficient travel.

2) Arbitrage is always efficient: Suppose you have two lanes, a fast and slow lane. If enough cars move from the fast to the slow lane so as to equalize the travel times, average speed will decrease for everyone. Moreover, such arbitrage always decreases variance speed across lanes, allowing drivers to better predict travel times.

3) Noise-Drivers are efficient: Suppose drivers randomly change lanes. As drivers spend more time in slow lanes than fast ones, over time highways will move to the efficient solution where travel times are constant (but, by Theorem 1, will probably never reach there).

There are other similarities, in the form of "traffic waves." Like manias, booms, and busts; traffic tends to cluster into times of congestion, which generally can't be fixed by shifts from individual drivers (investors). And just as financial instruments are ultimately a function of the real economy, highway travel ultimately depends on people getting to actual places.

Saturday, September 5, 2009

Does the Minimum Wage increase Unemployment?

Many studies find that minimum wage hikes have small effects on employment. To an extent, this is unsurprising--most people are paid well above the minimum wage. Alternately, employers can respond by cutting hours or benefits rather than employment.

But there's at least one subroup--teenagers--who should be much more affected by changes in the federal minimum wage, which just went up from 6.55 to 7.25 now.

Teenage unemployment? It's jumped to 25.5 percent, from 24 percent. Unemployment for everyone has gone up as well, to 9.7%.

Of course, this risecould be the result of many things--worsening labor markets, etc. But it's highly suggestive.

What we really need are wage subsidies. We have unemployment because wages are inflexible during recessions, as companies would rather fire people than deal with grumpy workers. Providing wage subsidies allows companies to pay less, while letting people take home the same amount of money in wages. Singapore has tried this (France as well) and found that unemployment stayed below 6%, even while GDP dropped somewhere in the double digits.

Doing this, combined with a payroll-tax holiday and mortgage modification plan, would do a whole lot more for struggling families than bridges to nowhere and a higher minimum wage.

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Kids These Days...

One of my pet peeves is people who complain that we don't read enough books, and how this spells cultural doom. Here's Matt Yglesias on the issue:

Between 1939 and 2009, human ingenuity has invented a lot of new things one can do with one’s time. Human ingenuity has not, however, invented a method for stuffing more hours into the day. Consequently, if you look at just about anything that people could do in 1939—read for pleasure, take care of children, cook, etc.—they do somewhat less of it in 2009. People who are really into books, or cooking, or natalism, or what have you tend to interpret this inevitable crowding of the timespace as a sign of cultural crisis and decline but it’s an inevitable result of heterogeneous preferences and innovation.

I feel that's about right. There's nothing particularly special about "books" or "classical music" or "theatre" that sets these apart from other media or cultural productions. Sure, they all have their strengths, but this means that we're all better off for having tons of options for consuming information and media. Maybe kids can't translate Latin or whatever as well as they used to; but that's inevitable as something has to give way as they pick up other skills and talents suited for today. Instead of worrying about how to force high school students to read things they aren't prepared to understand, schools should instead focus on how to introduce kids to a broad variety of media that they'd find interesting and accessible.

Twitter, however, is one social medium too far. It really is the sign of cultural decadence.